Everyone likes to indulge at some point. And what better way than biting into a creamy and fluffy peanut butter pie with an Oreo cookie crust? How about a totally organic version of this naughty delight!? I found the original recipe for this pie on a favorite food blog (The Pioneer Woman Cooks) but transformed her confection into an absolutely all natural version, which makes me feel slightly less guilty when going back for that second slice.
Organic Peanut Butter Pie with ‘Oreo’ Cookie Crust
If you really could care less about eating organically, by all means go ahead and make The Pioneer Woman’s delicious version of this pie. But if you’re interested in avoiding unnecessary fillers, high fructose corn syrup, and hydrogenated oils then try my version – I promise that it is just as tasty and you can trick yourself into thinking you’re eating something healthy!
- 25 ‘Newman O’s’ cookies, plus a few extra for crumbling on top of the finished pie (I’ve found these in both Food Lion and Harris Teeter)
- 4 tablespoons butter
- 1 cup all natural creamy peanut butter (Skippy and JIF both make all natural versions that don’t require stirring or refrigeration)
- 1 8 ounce block cream cheese (organic if you can find it)
- 1 1/2 cup powdered sugar
- 1 8 ounce carton heavy whipping cream (organic if you can find it)
Preheat your oven to 350 degrees. Place the Newman O’s cookies into a food processor and blend until the cookies are completely and finely crushed. Transfer to a small mixing bowl. Melt your butter in a small dish in the microwave (I cook it for about 15 seconds at a time until it’s all melted) then add the butter to the cookies crumbs. Stir to combine evenly. Pour your cookie mixture into a pie pan and carefully press and form it into an even crust using your hands, a spatula, or the back of a heavy measuring cup like I did. Bake for 6 minutes, remove from the oven, and let cool completely.
Whip your whipping cream in a stand mixer with the whisk attachment or in a large mixing bowl with your hand mixer until it is thick with stiff peaks (you won’t want runny whipped cream). Transfer to another bowl and refrigerate. As an aside, because I don’t sweeten the fresh whipped cream I add 1/4 cup more powdered sugar to the filling than The Pioneer Woman does, to account for the sweetness in the Cool Whip that she uses.
In the same mixer or mixing bowl, combine the peanut butter and cream cheese and mix on high until well combined. (Tip: spray the inside of your measuring cup with non-stick cooking spray before measuring the peanut butter to avoid any sticky mess.) Add the powdered sugar and whip again on high until smooth. Fold in the chilled whipped cream with a spatula until evenly combined and smooth and creamy. Pour the filling into your cooled crust, smooth out the top, and refrigerate for at least 2-3 hours, or overnight. Remove the pie from the fridge about 10 minutes before serving if your fridge is pretty cold like mine is and sprinkle with more crumbled cookies if desired.
If you’re anything like me, you’ll see this recipe and know you have to make it immediately (ok, I’ve already made it three times). But with my swapped out, all-organic ingredients you can at least have the peace of mind that while you may be indulging on a sinfully rich dessert you can rest assured that it’s all natural. Enjoy…




